Who is the "greatest player in SEC history?

[rorocanes]

Who is the "greatest" player in SEC history? Why not ask the board since EB said Reggie White..
discuss.. :popcorn

:lol: please link where I said that. Reggie white isn't even the best player to come out of Tennessee. If we are talking best overall career... Peyton manning. If you are talking college career it's a different story.

But Peyton is the best player to come out of any college ever so my answer is Peyton manning

Where would you rank Tee martin since he led the Vols to a Natty and he beat Fla something Peyton NEVER did...just aasking :dog

[ericberry14]

Who is the "greatest" player in SEC history? Why not ask the board since EB said Reggie White..
discuss.. :popcorn

:lol: please link where I said that. Reggie white isn't even the best player to come out of Tennessee. If we are talking best overall career... Peyton manning. If you are talking college career it's a different story.

But Peyton is the best player to come out of any college ever so my answer is Peyton manning

Where would you rank Tee martin since he led the Vols to a Natty and he beat Fla something Peyton NEVER did...just aasking :dog

Behind Peyton manning. Manning has had a better career than anyone.

[ericberry14]

Oh by the way you sound like a butthurt little bitch. Misquoting and pimpin the gaytors

[theSabanator20]

IMO....based strictly on college

Alabama-Derrick Thomas
Arkansas-Darren McFadden
Auburn-Bo Jackson
Florida-Tim Tebow
Georgia-Herschel Walker
Kentucky-Randall Cobb
LSU-Patrick Peterson
Mississippi State-Jackie Sherill
Ole Miss-Dexter McCluster
South Carolina-Sydney Rice
Tennessee-Peyton Manning
Vanderbilt-Jay Cutler

*** Texas A&M-Von Miller
*** Missouri-Jeremy Maclin

***used pre SEC era players because they have only been party of the SEC for 2 years.

[rorocanes]

Oh by the way you sound like a butthurt little bitch. Misquoting and pimpin the gaytors

:ROFL2

Im far from a little bitch youngone but you sound Butthurt... :dog
Oh yea I've Easley in play since pee wee(SIFL) and CTK high school in NYC...very proud of him and I hope he has a stellar NFL career.

[SmithsAUFan]

Either Bo Jackson or Hershel Walker.

[HUNKERED DOWN DAWG]

QB - Peyton Manning - Tennessee
QB 2 - Tebow - Florida
RB 1-Herschel Walker - Georgia
RB 2 - Bo Jackson - Auburn
WR 1 - Josh Reed - LSU
WR 2 - Hines Ward - Georgia
WR 3 - Sterling Sharpe - USCe
WR 4 - Don Hudson - Bama
TE 1 - Jason Witten - Tennessee
TE 2- Ozzie Newsome - Alabama
OL - John Hannah - Alabama
OL - Gene Upshaw - A&M
OL - Lomas Brown - Florida
OL - Richmond Webb - A&M
OL - Mike Pouncey - Florida

DE - Reggie White - Tennessee
DE - Jack Youngblood - Florida
DE - Julius Peppers - Georgia
DT - John Randle - A&M
DT - Glenn Dorsey - LSU
DT - John Henderson - Tennessee
LB - Derrick Thomas - Bama
LB - Wilber Marshall - Florida
LB - Leroy Jordan - Bama
LB - DD Lewis - Miss State
CB - Antonio Langham - Alabama
CB - Champ Bailey - Georgia
CB - Darrell Green - A&M
Safety - Eric Berry - Tennessee
Safety - Lawrence Wright - Florida

KR - Reidel Anthony - Florida
PR - Trenton Holliday - LSU

K - Jeff Chandler - Florida(couldn't think of anyone else tbh)
P - who cares

K--Kevin Butler --UGA.. may be a homer pick, but I remember him getting us out of some jams and winning games on crazy long field goals. One in particular, a 60 yarder against Clemson.

[johnnybravo23]

FYI, I was messing with EB, about Reggie White being the best Tennessee player. But really when you think about it it's Peyton Manning 1a and Reggie White 1b in my eyes. Both dominate, and well respected players. :yes

[FSUKW]

Simple:

1) Tim Tebow
2) Herschel Walker
3) Peyton Manning
4) Bo Jackson

[JdPat04]

Well this says SEC history so wouldn't NFL play be out of context?

[ericberry14]

Well this says SEC history so wouldn't NFL play be out of context?

Depends on if you mean best football player (manning) or best sec career (probably tebow)

[MIAMIDOMINATION]

Who is the "greatest" player in SEC history? Why not ask the board since EB said Reggie White..
discuss.. :popcorn

:lol: please link where I said that. Reggie white isn't even the best player to come out of Tennessee. If we are talking best overall career... Peyton manning. If you are talking college career it's a different story.

But Peyton is the best player to come out of any college ever so my answer is Peyton manning

reggie white might be the greatest defensive player in NFL history bro...

hes definitely better than manning

[ericberry14]

Who is the "greatest" player in SEC history? Why not ask the board since EB said Reggie White..
discuss.. :popcorn

:lol: please link where I said that. Reggie white isn't even the best player to come out of Tennessee. If we are talking best overall career... Peyton manning. If you are talking college career it's a different story.

But Peyton is the best player to come out of any college ever so my answer is Peyton manning

reggie white might be the greatest defensive player in NFL history bro...

hes definitely better than manning

Tennessee has produced the best offensive and defensive players ever... This is true. But qb > de and Peyton is tops.

[JdPat04]

Well this says SEC history so wouldn't NFL play be out of context?

Depends on if you mean best football player (manning) or best sec career (probably tebow)

McArron ain't done yet hombre

[ericberry14]

Well this says SEC history so wouldn't NFL play be out of context?

Depends on if you mean best football player (manning) or best sec career (probably tebow)

McArron ain't done yet hombre

He'd have to win the heisman and break some sec passing records. No clue where he is on those.

[rorocanes]

Who is the "greatest" player in SEC history? Why not ask the board since EB said Reggie White..
discuss.. :popcorn

:lol: please link where I said that. Reggie white isn't even the best player to come out of Tennessee. If we are talking best overall career... Peyton manning. If you are talking college career it's a different story.

But Peyton is the best player to come out of any college ever so my answer is Peyton manning

reggie white might be the greatest defensive player in NFL history bro...

hes definitely better than manning

Reggie White the best D-lineman I ever saw. But LT is the best all round defensive player I ever saw in the NFL,he changed the game.IMO

[SmithsAUFan]

Well this says SEC history so wouldn't NFL play be out of context?

Depends on if you mean best football player (manning) or best sec career (probably tebow)

You could argue that Herschel Walker had the best SEC career.

Herschel Walker
Over 5,000 yards rushing in 3 years. He would have spent 4 years in college if the USFL wasn't around. If he had not have gone pro then he would more than likely surpassed 7,000 yards rushing.

Bo Jackson
Probably one of the best athletes of all time. Rushed for over 4,000 yards in 4 years(practically 3 seasons due to missing most of one season due to bad shoulder). He finished a baseball career of batting .335, hitting 28 HRs and 70 RBIs and 19 SBs in three seasons. He missed one season because of an injury that he sustained playing football. He also qualified for NCAA nationals in track and field for his freshmen and sophomore seasons.

[JdPat04]

Well this says SEC history so wouldn't NFL play be out of context?

Depends on if you mean best football player (manning) or best sec career (probably tebow)

McArron ain't done yet hombre

He'd have to win the heisman and break some sec passing records. No clue where he is on those.

Heisman yes, records no.

His hands are full of rings, he's thrown just what 10 interceptions so far, he'd be one of the winningest if not the winningest (not too sure what the record is) and records aren't needed.


Look at Murray. He has records yet not seen as "great" considering he can't win big games, etc...

Exactly the opposite for AJ

[HUNKERED DOWN DAWG]

Well this says SEC history so wouldn't NFL play be out of context?

Depends on if you mean best football player (manning) or best sec career (probably tebow)

You could argue that Herschel Walker had the best SEC career.

Herschel Walker
Over 5,000 yards rushing in 3 years. He would have spent 4 years in college if the USFL wasn't around. If he had not have gone pro then he would more than likely surpassed 7,000 yards rushing.
Bo Jackson
Probably one of the best athletes of all time. Rushed for over 4,000 yards in 4 years(practically 3 seasons due to missing most of one season due to bad shoulder). He finished a baseball career of batting .335, hitting 28 HRs and 70 RBIs and 19 SBs in three seasons. He missed one season because of an injury that he sustained playing football. He also qualified for NCAA nationals in track and field for his freshmen and sophomore seasons.

not to mention that when these guys played, bowl game stats were not included in career stats....and they played fewer games in a season.

[rorocanes]

IMO....based strictly on college

Alabama-Derrick Thomas
Arkansas-Darren McFadden
Auburn-Bo Jackson
Florida-Tim Tebow
Georgia-Herschel Walker
Kentucky-Randall Cobb
LSU-Patrick Peterson
Mississippi State-Jackie Sherill
Ole Miss-Dexter McCluster
South Carolina-Sydney Rice
Tennessee-Peyton Manning
Vanderbilt-Jay Cutler

*** Texas A&M-Von Miller
*** Missouri-Jeremy Maclin

***used pre SEC era players because they have only been party of the SEC for 2 years.

I would say Archie Manning at Ole Miss over McCluster..IMO