FSUKW wrote:Jezter13 wrote:I judge greatness by quantifying the surrounding offensive talent. The rules for defense. The division they play in. And what they actually meant to the nfl because of how they played, meaning did defenses have to create and or make a new style tl defend.
I don't have a particular order as i think each was as important as the other. I don't think putting an order to them has a right or wrong sequence.
Dan Marino
Johnny Unitas
John Elway
Tom Brady
Steve McNair
Jim Kelly
Randall Cunningham
Good list - I would add Montana, Manning, Favre. I think any of these QB's (and probably more) could do well if you swapped Brady for them.
Montana was decent. But not great until he was surrounded by Walsb and all the Hall of Famers that made it easy for the likes of Grbac, Young, Garcia, etc to throw for probowl like numberz in an era that only the really goid ones could.
Favre threw more interceptions than anyone in history of the gsme. Doing so with a great OL and Top Flight wrs anc runners. He threw more than anyone during his time too. Watching Rodgers step in and nothing changed? Nahhh.
Manning is the prime example of why the nfl sucks today. They changed the rules in 2004 so hs could stop getting his ass handed fo him in the playoffs and provide him an opportunity to not continue being one and done. His numbers were average until that rule change too. He played in ths weakest division in football after the texans were franchsed too. Another of his whines. Anyone question how it is and why it is the Coltz ended up in ths afc south as opposed to ths phins? And Don't say because the jaguars and same state, seeing as the jets and bills play inter-divisional.
I cannot argue your opinion, it is yours and there's truly no wrong answer when discussing these kinds of things, but I would never put them on my team.
As an example, before I'd consider them? I'd have Warren Moon, Donovan McNabb, Dan Fouts, Fran Tarkenton etc.
Like i said, i consider surrounding talent, conference and their direct effect on the game.