Jimhowlett wrote:JdPat04 wrote:MIAMIDOMINATION wrote:Congrats to osu
They deserved the title, and many said they should have not made the playoff over tcu or baylot
And the case that was made for them not making it was legit.
If the nfl playoffs held a team less from each spot then the giants shouldn't have been in the playoffs when they beat the patriots.
I can't remember all of that year that great only the main part of it. However if you was talking about teams that deserved to make it and not make it the giants weren't that good at the moment. They got hot and they best every team.
That's the same with osu.
Since Baylor or tcu didn't get the chance to do the same then you can't sit there and say that osu is the legit one of you've ever bitched about the BCS or any other champion before.
Baylor didn't even win their conference...and they ended up choking to MSU, a team we dominated. So I don't buy that they deserved to be in over us. TCU is a whole different story though.
I don't think anyone was going to beat us the way we were playing in the postseason though.
Baylor beat TCU
So Baylor did win their conference as well.
However just because Baylor lost to msu doesn't mean they wouldn't have beat Bama and Oregon. They might've got the shit beat out of them as well. We never will know.
I'm not making the case that osu didn't deserve to win because we saw them play, the won it no doubt.
I am making a case that MD is just being typical md.
Baylor and TCU both had just as much reason or more to play over osu. For a few reasons IMO. I am going with Baylor deserved it the most.
As I said they could've got beat, however we never know. Hell if you go by the games that were played then it should've been Oregon, tcu, osu, and Bama.
But you can't do that. You rank them by several factors.
Of course Baylor got beat, and TcU won.
Baylor could've lost because of the "Bama letdown :lolthumb"
Tcu could've won their bowl game because they felt disrespected and pissed off instead of more let down and bummed out.
So had tcu got in they could've won or got demolished.
Had Baylor got in they could've demolished or been demolished.
If osu got left out they could've been let down and lost their bowl game.
I am by no means saying osu isn't the champion. You are. I am just saying that unlike what md is saying it's not so black and white and he's acting now.
We already knew this would happen most of the time with a 4 team playoff the same way it happened with the BCS.